Battoo/PIWM Fraud Provides a Teachable Moment for Investors
Last week, the SEC filed charges against Nikolai Battoo, a hedge fund manager who claimed to manage $1.5 billion on behalf of investors around the world, including at least $100 million in the United States. Battoo had credited himself with producing an impressive performance throughout the 2008 global financial crisis, but he apparently inflated the value of the assets he managed and at the same time concealed major losses from his investors. The SEC obtained an order freezing the assets of Battoo and two of his companies, BC Capital Group S.A. and BC Capital Group Limited, to prevent further harm to investors in the U.S.
In the same complaint, the SEC also charged Tracy Lee Sunderlage for his involvement with Battoo’s investment program. Since 2005, in violation of an industry bar order for a prior fraud, Sunderlage acted as an unregistered broker-dealer and investment advisor overseeing a complex investment program through his companies, Maven Assurance, Ltd. and Maven Life International. Sunderlage received substantial fees and commissions for selling variable annuities and other securities to Maven clients, many of whom purchased such products through self-directed IRAs using U.S.-based IRA custodians. According to the SEC, 80% to 95% of the amount paid by the Maven investors was ultimately invested in Battoo's PIWM portfolios. A key selling point for Maven products was the supposedly high return from Battoo’s PIWM portfolios. By 2008, Battoo was managing about $70 million associated with Maven products and that amount has since grown to about $95 million.
This story gives us another chance to remind you of the most important rule for avoiding investment fraud. It’s similar to the old aphorism, “If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.” But we hate clichés, and that one has the double whammy of being grammatically ambiguous, so try this. Claims of extraordinary investment returns should be met with extraordinary skepticism.
This Battoo guy is a perfect example. The SEC’s complaint alleges that Battoo pitched himself as a highly successful alternative asset manager with a track record unblemished by the global financial crisis of 2008. Battoo hyped his purported success to existing and prospective investors at a “due diligence conference” that he and Sunderlage sponsored at the Four Seasons Hotel in Las Vegas in January 2009. Promotional material for that conference asked boastfully, “How is it that PIWM-I can produce positive results or significantly reduce market losses when nearly everyone else is losing 35 to 50%?” Now we know the answer. It couldn’t and it didn’t.
The SEC, which has described Battoo's financial empire as an amorphous syndicate of funds, entities, and affiliates, indicated that Battoo manages significant assets for companies that sell investment products to U.S. investors, and has investment proceeds channeled to him by a network of U.S.-based investment advisers. Battoo also allegedly has created individualized client portfolios that he manages under the PIWM brand name. These portfolios consist of holdings in several hedge funds he manages, holdings in other hedge funds, and other investments.
During the past several months, investors had been requesting redemptions on their investments with Battoo. But instead of paying them, Battoo provided excuses ranging from blaming the MF Global collapse to claiming that holds had been placed on investors’ money due to government investigations. The SEC says he was lying. Here’s an excerpt from the Commission’s press release summarizing the complaint:
"Battoo arranged for “asset verifications” in 2009 to reassure clients that their money was safe and secure following the market collapse. The asset verifications, however, contained false and backdated information. For example, they identify investments in at least seven hedge funds that Battoo did not manage. Battoo’s actual investments in these hedge funds amounted to about $9 million while his asset verifications falsely stated the investments to be worth approximately $33 million. Moreover, these asset verifications improperly included backdated investments that also inflated the value of the PIWM portfolios."
The press release continues:
"…[W]hile Battoo claimed success, he actually sustained particularly heavy losses in 2008. First, he was terminated as an investment adviser to the master fund of a large international bank, which terminated him from a “fund linked certificate” program through which Battoo-managed hedge funds collectively invested about $138 million. After Battoo’s termination, the net asset value of the hedge fund managed for the bank plummeted by nearly 50 percent, and Battoo’s losses on the fund-linked certificates exceeded $100 million. The other major loss suffered by Battoo’s asset management business later that year flowed from Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, in which several Battoo-managed hedge funds were heavily invested. However, following Madoff’s arrest, Battoo assured his investors that the Madoff fraud had only a nominal or minimal impact on the portfolios. However, several Battoo-managed portfolios held substantial investments in hedge funds that fed into the Madoff scheme. In fact, Battoo had borrowed money to amplify the size of his Madoff investments. Battoo similarly concealed from investors the losses stemming from the fund-linked certificates. Without knowledge of these substantial losses, investors have collectively invested tens of millions of dollars with Battoo since 2009."
If you feel like reading the SEC complaint, which (we kid you not) actually contains the line, “the jig appears to be up,” you can find it here.